[SCOT goes POP!] Data tables from the poll of SNP members show that Kate Forbes has a big lead among older SNP members - and she would need just *76%* of Ash Regan's second preferences to become the next First Minister

[ALBA-Bot]

Data tables from the poll of SNP members show that Kate Forbes has a big lead among older SNP members - and she would need just *76%* of Ash Regan's second preferences to become the next First Minister

To their credit, Savanta have already released the data tables from the first poll of SNP members in the leadership contest, and I've been having a look at them.  On the raw weighted numbers, there are 139 respondents for Humza Yousaf, 114 for Kate Forbes, and 50 for Ash Regan.  If, hypothetically, the Don't Knows end up being distributed between the candidates in the same way as those who have already reached a view, it would mean Forbes will win if Ash Regan's second preferences break just over 3-1 in her favour, which is a less daunting task than the headline percentages led us to believe earlier.  76% of Regan's second preferences in this poll would give Forbes 152 respondents, leaving Humza Yousaf with just 151.  That hinges, of course, on Regan's supporters all using their second preferences, and one of the biggest priorities for Forbes will be ensuring that as many as possible of them do.

Bear in mind that every poll has a margin of error, and in this case it'll be a bit larger than normal because there were only 500 respondents.  If Yousaf's first preference lead is being overestimated, the road to victory for Forbes on the second count could be extremely straightforward and easy.  If it's being underestimated, Forbes' chances may be a fair bit slimmer.

The tables confirm some of the previously untested assumptions of this campaign, because it turns out there's an absolutely enormous disparity between the different age groups.  The reason Forbes is in with a real shout is precisely because, as speculated in The National a few days ago, older SNP members are backing her and they happen to represent the bulk of the membership.  Among 55-64 year old members, Forbes has a 15 percentage point lead over Yousaf (after Don't Knows are excluded), and among over-65s, she has a 10-point advantage.  So the accuracy of this poll will depend on whether Savanta have got the target weightings for each age group correct.  They look in the right ball-park to me, but the reality is that I'm not sure accurate information about the SNP's current membership is even publicly available.

UPDATE: Also worthy of note is that Yousaf has a significant first preference lead among female party members, but among male party members Forbes is essentially tied.  That seems counterintuitive, but this would be far from the first election in the world where the gender gap was 'the wrong way round', so to speak.

11% of the original sample in this poll, some 55 people (bigger than the gap between Yousaf and Forbes on first preferences) told Savanta that they "prefer not to answer" the question.  That's very different from saying "don't know" because it may imply they do know who they will vote for but want to keep it a secret. Could that be the "Shy Kate" factor that was speculated about on the previous thread? SNP members who are too embarrassed to admit they will vote for Forbes in case they're called "far-right bigoted transphobes who are probably married to BEARDED TORIES"?  Best not to jump to that conclusion, actually, because whenever there is a "prefer not to answer" option in a poll, some respondents will select it.  But it's an interesting thought, and if there are a significant number of Shy Kate voters out there, Yousaf could be in a bit of a hole.

*  *  *

If you'd like to help Scot Goes Pop continue in some form, donations are welcome.  The simplest method is a direct Paypal payment. My Paypal email address is:

jkellysta@yahoo.co.uk

If you wish, you can add a note saying "for the fundraiser", although even if you don't do that, it'll be fairly obvious what the payment is for.

(I'm going to punt the Paypal option for a while, because I received a strange message the other night implying that there might soon be a delay in GoFundMe's payment processing. But if you don't have a Paypal account, last year's fundraiser is still open for donations HERE.)

Source: Data tables from the poll of SNP members show that Kate Forbes has a big lead among older SNP members - and she would need just *76%* of Ash Regan's second preferences to become the next First Minister